Customer Reviews
★★★★☆
4.46 out of 5 · 28 reviews
★★★★★
Perfect
Javier Nunez · December 16, 2025 · ✓ Verified · Customer review
Good
★★★★★
REAL leather construction.
CRstopher · January 03, 2023 · ✓ Verified · Customer review
Exactly as described and in perfect order. Previous pairs were good for about 180 wearings.
★★★★★
This is a great replacement for Johnson Murphy penny loafer. Excellent workmanship and quality.
Yes it's me · October 21, 2021 · ✓ Verified · Customer review
I have been a Johnson Murphy purchaser for over thirty years. However when they discontinued the penny loafer I had to find a replacement.This company makes an excellent penny loafer, it is on a par with the old Johnson Murphy.
★★★★★
Excellent Shoes
MEL PAZMAN · April 28, 2019 · ✓ Verified · Customer review
Finally, I got the shoes I've been looking for. I recommend it to others.
★★★★★
Bought them for my brother. He loves them so much
LassoAmazon CustomerLasso · January 16, 2019 · ✓ Verified · Customer review
Long lasting and classic dress shoes
★★★★★
Good Product
SEBASTIEN · October 25, 2018 · ✓ Verified · Customer review
Good quality shoes. Fit as expected.
★★★★★
The Fit is Better
Carla A Goodwin, PhD · August 23, 2018 · ✓ Verified · Customer review
My husband has worn this shoe for 20 yrs plus ... And he said fit is betterthan last pair. They are a classic shoe with well known style
★★★★☆
Four Stars
Milu · February 01, 2018 · ✓ Verified · Customer review
The quelity is good, but sizing is a bit to the large side
★★★★★
Good price for value Sebago
Hervé · October 28, 2017 · ✓ Verified · Customer review
Used to buy these shoes, about every 2 years... Just as expected : good quality and good price :-).
★★★★☆
Four Stars
D D · August 21, 2017 · ✓ Verified · Customer review
Nice shoes
★★★★☆
Like the style
Bob Beaudry · April 04, 2017 · ✓ Verified · Customer review
Somewhat smaller in width than expected but leather is expanding as I wear the shoes.
★★★★☆
and other times it is pretty darn tight
Alvino-Mario Fantini · February 17, 2017 · ✓ Verified · Customer review
These are my go-to loafers for heavy use in sometimes sloppy conditions. I usually expect to pay between, say, US$ 65 to 125. I usually have one rubber-soled pair and another with a leather sole.My only complaint is that the same cut or size -- in my case 9E -- is always slightly different: sometimes it fits perfectly, with even some wiggle room after it stretches and opens up; and other times it is pretty darn tight, and I need a shoe horn and some elbow grease to get them on. Strange.Generally, I would describe Sebago loafers, whether rubber- or leather-soled, a solid item.
★★★★★
Great Quality Shoe
Rudy Augsburger · November 19, 2016 · ✓ Verified · Customer review
Great quality shoes, yes somewhat stiff at the beginning, but as expected, these slowly mould themselves to your feet, and you know they will become your favorites . . .
★★★★☆
0 overall I'm happy..
Carlito · May 29, 2016 · ✓ Verified · Customer review
I cannot go wrong with sebago but I should get8.5 instead of 8.0 overall I'm happy..
★★★★☆
The customer service person was the problem The shoes are great Sebago customer service is
Amazon Customer · October 25, 2015 · ✓ Verified · Customer review
I called Sebago and I used another Sebago shoe as a comparison. The customer service person was the problem The shoes are great Sebago customer service is terrible
★★★★★
looking good
SANDY T · May 26, 2015 · ✓ Verified · Customer review
Great shoes had to send them back was to large with no problem got a smaller size in 2day My son didnt think he would like a loafer but its a classic was in church on Sunday
★★★★☆
Excellent product
John · May 05, 2015 · ✓ Verified · Customer review
Very pleased. This is my second pair and the are a very comfortable shoe.
★★★★☆
Good looking, not too comfortable
M.D. · March 05, 2015 · ✓ Verified · Customer review
Looks really good but the leather is hard and the wide size I ordered is really not that wide. So it's not that comfortable
★★★★☆
Four Stars
juan jose de la llera · February 09, 2015 · ✓ Verified · Customer review
Perfect
★★★★☆
... the size after reading other reviews but they fit great. Maybe the slightest bit tight on the width ...
Scott P. · August 22, 2014 · ✓ Verified · Customer review
I was concerned about the size after reading other reviews but they fit great. Maybe the slightest bit tight on the width but that may be because they need to be broke in.
★★★★☆
Good shoe for the price, but some issues
T. Jensen · June 15, 2014 · ✓ Verified · Customer review
The regular brown leather feels considerably better than the other colours I've tried (black and the purple/red brown -- cordovan?), which are a bit shiny and stiff. I've worn completely through the sole of one pair (had it resoled with vibram) and am wearing down the other. The only reason these don't get a five is that the insoles have come completely loose (on both my pairs) and at this point have a tendency to slip down into the toe of the shoe over the course of the day. I could even downgrade to a 3 for this, except that the shoe is more or less exactly what I want apart from this defect. This doesn't seem to happen with the black or cordovan coloured pairs.
★★★★☆
If you know about this design you should like it.
Alex Cho · May 01, 2014 · ✓ Verified · Customer review
I have been looking for this design for years and fail to find the right one many many times. This pair will stay with me for a long time
★★★★★
Same classic
Viktor Berggren · February 12, 2014 · ✓ Verified · Customer review
Ordered a pair of size 8 1/2 E, just like the previous ones I've been having for the last 10 years, and another pair 10 years before that. Great price (a third compared to Sweden), great fitting and so far they seem as durable as the ones before. Mine was produced in the Philippines.
★★★★☆
Great looking shoe
WM · January 19, 2014 · ✓ Verified · Customer review
I bought this shoe a little bigger than I normally wear based on customer reviews and the shoes fit a little loose because of that decision. Still they are comfortable and appear to be well made with high quality leather and soles. Recommend them for wear in the office or casual with jeans.
★★★★☆
Sizes are accurate
Christopher Torres · November 22, 2013 · ✓ Verified · Customer review
I normally wear a size 9 however I read some reviews that stated the shoes ran small. I ordered a size ten which was too large; I returned them for the size nine and they fit great.
★★★★★
Fit well, looks really nice shinny!!!
Tiago · May 07, 2013 · ✓ Verified · Customer review
The pair I ordered fit well. Some reviewers mentioned that it runs small or tight so I ordered a size-E (width) instead of size-D (my normal width size). This is my third pair of Sebago. I started wearing them since I was 12 years old. I had my previous pair for over 18 years and resoled once, (I probably wear it once a month because I have a lot of shoes). I like the Sebago look, style, and fit, not to mention shinning it. This shoes looks so nice when its shinny!!I also had it shipped to an Amazon Locker -- really useful and convenient if you are worried about your package getting stolen.
★★★★☆
Sebago mens classic
GD Horne · April 12, 2012 · ✓ Verified · Customer review
I am new to buying online from Amazon I live in New ZealandI took what I thought was a risk buying shoes sight unseenI have been amazed at the speedy service from Amazon - only daysfor the shoes to arrive from the USThe shoes were a steal compared with prices here in New ZealandQuality is good ( not superb - but still good)the shoes fit well despite US sizing being different to ourswell done - a very happy shopper
★★★★★
Sebago Shoes - Penny Loafer
Manuel P. Amargo · April 23, 2011 · ✓ Verified · Customer review
I got my "Sebago Men's Classic Loafer - Cord" and I love it very much. I love this kind and the brand of shoes since when I was in High School( 1970's). It is just this time I only bought this. It is leather in material and the quality as well and also the brand name.